{ "schemaVersion": "deck-intelligence.v1", "id": "019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "slug": "b4cdf04ed0fb", "title": "eHealth Inc. (EHTH)", "subtitle": "Carson Block · 2020-04", "author": "Carson Block", "date": "2020-04-08 00:00:00", "pageCount": 15, "kind": "research-note", "orientation": "portrait", "aspectRatio": 0.77272725, "targetCompany": "eHealth Inc.", "targetTicker": "EHTH", "document": { "id": "019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "slug": "b4cdf04ed0fb", "title": "eHealth Inc. (EHTH)", "rawTitle": "MW EHTH 04082020", "authorId": "51_Muddy_Waters", "authorName": "Carson Block", "authorDisplay": "Carson Block", "kind": { "slug": "research-note", "label": "Research note" }, "sourceType": { "slug": "short_seller", "label": "Short seller" }, "fileName": "2020-04-MW_EHTH_04082020.pdf", "sourceUrl": null, "sourceDate": "2020-08-04 00:00:00", "presentationDate": "2020-04-08 00:00:00", "ingestedAt": "2026-04-22 19:43:55+00", "status": "ready", "pageCount": 15, "orientation": "portrait", "aspectRatio": 0.77272725, "targetCompany": "eHealth Inc.", "targetTicker": "EHTH", "metadata": { "local_root": "/tmp/legacy-images/b4cdf04ed0fb", "activist_firm": "Muddy Waters Research", "origin_corpus": "contrarian", "extraction_seconds": 123.10409903526306 } }, "coverage": { "pageCount": 15, "pagesIndexed": 15, "pagesWithImages": 15, "pagesWithMetadata": 15, "imageCoveragePct": 100, "metadataCoveragePct": 100, "componentCount": 111, "chartCount": 1, "metricSlides": 0, "toolMatches": 6, "documentToolMatches": 4, "frameworkMatches": 10, "arcMatches": 1, "beatMatches": 6, "loopMatches": 3, "patternMatches": 0, "storymakersMatch": false, "scoreAvailable": false, "reviewAvailable": false, "activistThesisAvailable": true, "pitchdeckMetadataAvailable": false, "pitchdeckProfileAvailable": false }, "blocks": [], "matches": { "arcs": [ { "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Booker's 7 Plots", "categorySlug": "booker-s-7-plots" }, "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "evidence": "The report follows a narrative of critiquing EHTH's business practices and financials, ultimately concluding that its stock is a promotion", "isPrimary": true, "confidence": 0.8, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.575178+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "beats": [ { "to": 3, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Booker's 7 Plots", "categorySlug": "booker-s-7-plots" }, "from": 1, "name": "Disclaimer and Executive Summary", "beatId": "dde77bb7-5dca-4829-8738-bf5685e58ab4", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": { "name": "Hook", "slug": "hook", "status": "active", "canonId": "019dd9b8-01a6-7328-bff2-b22eb40b3ea5", "version": 1, "description": "The opener — a deliberate move to earn attention before any argument. Used by AIDA, Monroes, Pixar Pitch, Overcoming the Monster." }, "evidence": "The report begins with a disclaimer and executive summary, setting the tone for the rest of the report", "position": 0, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 7, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Booker's 7 Plots", "categorySlug": "booker-s-7-plots" }, "from": 4, "name": "Critique of EHTH's Business Practices", "beatId": "a7d2bd7d-d3e2-4d86-8aa9-29ef2dc6e3b2", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report critiques EHTH's business practices, including its overly optimistic member persistence assumptions", "position": 1, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 11, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Booker's 7 Plots", "categorySlug": "booker-s-7-plots" }, "from": 8, "name": "Exposure of EHTH's Contradictions", "beatId": "28e1c45d-1e7d-4f4d-9e61-ac306c4fa834", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, including its deliberate obscuring of increasing churn rates", "position": 2, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Booker's 7 Plots", "categorySlug": "booker-s-7-plots" }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 13, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Booker's 7 Plots", "categorySlug": "booker-s-7-plots" }, "from": 13, "name": "Valuation Table", "beatId": "313b7d4b-d08b-4fcf-881a-6d9569070037", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report presents a valuation table showing EHTH's Medicare Advantage business is significantly loss-generating", "position": 4, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 15, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Booker's 7 Plots", "categorySlug": "booker-s-7-plots" }, "from": 14, "name": "Final Critique of EHTH", "beatId": "aac76673-f7bf-4429-a612-c39f711d135f", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report concludes with a final critique of EHTH, viewing it as little more than a stock promotion", "position": 5, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 7, "from": 4, "loop": { "name": "06_zoom_in", "slug": "06-zoom-in", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Technical deep-dives, case studies, detailed analysis", "canonId": "019dd956-6846-74db-82be-dff5b058b072", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Big Picture -> Key Area of Focus -> Specific Detail -> Implication", "description": "Start broad, then progressively focus on specific details that prove your point", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Analysis", "categorySlug": "analysis" }, "matchId": "69c5fb1b-d8a2-4668-b25e-a5d752abdd93", "evidence": "The report zooms in on EHTH's business practices and financials, critiquing its overly optimistic assumptions", "position": 0, "objective": "What are EHTH's business practices and financials?", "confidence": 0.8, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.899042+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } }, { "to": 11, "from": 8, "loop": { "name": "10_iceberg", "slug": "10-iceberg", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Consulting, complex problem solving, organizational change", "canonId": "019dd956-69f4-738c-852a-643798da0899", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Symptom (Visible) -> The System (Hidden) -> The Root Cause", "description": "Reveal that the visible problem is merely a symptom of a deeper root cause", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Analysis", "categorySlug": "analysis" }, "matchId": "38a6f789-a22a-4dbe-9534-a7c98a2ea885", "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, revealing the iceberg beneath the surface", "position": 1, "objective": "What are the implications of EHTH's contradictions?", "confidence": 0.7, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.936524+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } }, { "to": 13, "from": 13, "loop": { "name": "27_cost_of_inaction", "slug": "27-cost-of-inaction", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Urgent budget requests, compliance, risk mitigation", "canonId": "019dd956-70d1-7395-a15b-857ba858b394", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Status Quo -> The Hidden Costs Accumulating -> The Future State of Inaction -> The Tipping Point", "description": "Quantify what happens if the audience does nothing", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": "Urgency", "categorySlug": "urgency" }, "matchId": "c4f27b16-be6e-4fb3-8ddd-617fe8ec5192", "evidence": "The report presents a valuation table showing the cost of inaction for EHTH's investors", "position": 2, "objective": "What is the cost of inaction for EHTH's investors?", "confidence": 0.6, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.973822+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "tools": [ { "tool": { "name": "CEO quote contradiction", "slug": "ceo-quote-contradiction", "status": "active", "bestFor": "When management credibility is the lever", "canonId": "019dd9e1-52e9-717f-8454-93e627563ed6", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019dd9a1-8296-720d-8f51-da76937f9415", "description": "You reproduce management's own words — verbatim, with source and date — and\nthen place them next to the outcome that contradicts them. The CEO built\nthe rope; you put it around their own neck.", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "document", "agents": null, "matchId": "baeda08d-b2af-4f64-bee3-95f3c840cb89", "evidence": null, "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": "When management credibility is the lever", "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-29 12:07:50.005477+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": null, "whyItWorks": "- **Maximum credibility**: no adjective you could write is as damning as the\n target's own prior statement.\n- **No rebuttal path**: management can't argue they didn't say it.\n- **It forces accountability onto a person**, not an institution — even if\n you aren't explicitly naming a villain elsewhere.\n- **Reporters amplify it**. A CEO-quote-contradiction slide is quotable,\n which means it lands in WSJ/FT/Bloomberg coverage.", "antipattern": null, "cardinality": null, "narrativePurpose": null }, { "tool": { "name": "Sum of parts", "slug": "sum-of-parts", "status": "active", "bestFor": "For breakup / spin-off theses", "canonId": "019dd9e1-51e5-73ad-9d1e-e77d4afe3125", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-9ecd-71db-8fa1-5f5eff36697f", "description": "You break the target into its constituent businesses or asset classes, value\neach separately against its own peer set, and show that the total is\nmaterially greater than the current market capitalisation. The \"gap\" is the\nconglomerate discount — or worse, accounting opacity hiding a crown-jewel\nasset.", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "document", "agents": null, "matchId": "f80e9ab2-4006-4ff5-83ba-8feb3e166d66", "evidence": null, "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": "For breakup / spin-off theses", "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-29 12:07:50.005477+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": null, "whyItWorks": "- It forces the market to confront **mismatched valuation multiples**:\n \"this company trades like X but owns Y, which trades at", "antipattern": null, "cardinality": null, "narrativePurpose": null }, { "tool": { "name": "Villain naming", "slug": "villain-naming", "status": "active", "bestFor": "When governance or specific decisions are the core thesis", "canonId": "019dd9e1-55a4-74db-9314-0ced4cd46cd2", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019dd9a1-88f1-72ad-8f4e-56ec29d7b369", "description": "You identify a **specific person** responsible for the target's underperformance\nor the behaviour you want changed — and name them. Not \"management\" or \"the\nboard\". A named executive or director with a specific failure attributable to\nthem.", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "document", "agents": null, "matchId": "be5a3009-2ba4-4ada-b774-7c97e3aa43e1", "evidence": "Scott Flanders (CEO) and Dave Francis (COO)", "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": "When governance or specific decisions are the core thesis", "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-29 12:07:50.005477+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": null, "whyItWorks": "- **Accountability needs a face.** Voters (shareholders, regulators,\n journalists) act faster against people than institutions.\n- **Credibility rises with specificity.** \"The CFO has repeatedly missed\n guidance\" > \"Management has missed guidance\".\n- It **pre-empts evasion**. An individual can be removed; an abstraction\n cannot.\n- It **forces the target to respond personally** — and their defensive\n response usually generates more attention for your thesis.", "antipattern": null, "cardinality": null, "narrativePurpose": null }, { "tool": { "name": "Villain slide", "slug": "villain-slide", "status": "active", "bestFor": "In activist decks where the personality matters", "canonId": "019dd9e1-518c-7404-976a-5be5a517b659", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "A dedicated slide presenting the named villain visually", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "document", "agents": null, "matchId": "fbbe98b8-b7d1-461f-87b5-1ac9163bd764", "evidence": null, "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": "In activist decks where the personality matters", "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-29 12:07:50.005477+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": null, "whyItWorks": "Makes the antagonist concrete", "antipattern": null, "cardinality": null, "narrativePurpose": null }, { "tool": { "name": "Executive summary", "slug": "executive-summary", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-4b63-72d5-9734-da757d91ca61", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "A condensed view of the entire argument on a single slide / block.", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "slide", "agents": null, "matchId": "b61d2fe9-12d7-4a12-b0be-bc8c7a6e93fa", "evidence": "type: executive_summary", "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-17 03:55:28.626868+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 2, "whyItWorks": null, "antipattern": null, "cardinality": "common", "narrativePurpose": null }, { "tool": { "name": "Executive summary", "slug": "executive-summary", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-4b63-72d5-9734-da757d91ca61", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "A condensed view of the entire argument on a single slide / block.", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "slide", "agents": null, "matchId": "f7bafb9f-9207-41db-ba71-f37ac71356da", "evidence": "type: executive_summary", "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-17 03:55:28.690759+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 3, "whyItWorks": null, "antipattern": null, "cardinality": "common", "narrativePurpose": null } ], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "f00b374b-4dbe-4332-80e6-659d5dad7af3", "evidence": "The slide explicitly outlines allegations of aggressive accounting, misleading management, and value destruction.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.139+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 2, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" }, { "matchId": "c001c9c5-6148-49e4-920b-3c380376c91e", "evidence": "The text explicitly argues that management manipulated business operations to exploit accounting standards (ASC 606) for stock promotion.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:47.872+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 3, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" }, { "matchId": "9fdb1dd6-48cd-4059-a92e-84d337962a5c", "evidence": "Critique of manipulated methodology and overstatement of revenue.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 4, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" }, { "matchId": "802cdb0c-ff74-47ee-abde-d20114ecf386", "evidence": "Use of former executive quotes to validate the thesis on churn.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.562+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 7, "frameworkName": "authority-citation" }, { "matchId": "7c84452b-ebeb-45e6-bc79-9d959d8a1aa5", "evidence": "Critique of accounting methodology and churn calculation", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 9, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" }, { "matchId": "85b4aa3b-3cf6-4dd0-bea6-6955fe9b7ece", "evidence": "Argues that company accounting ignores real costs to inflate revenue recognition.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 10, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" }, { "matchId": "b0179c54-5f5c-47a1-af75-e3bda5cd66f8", "evidence": "The slide explicitly frames management statements as 'disingenuous' and 'misleading' to expose potential financial misrepresentation.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 11, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" }, { "matchId": "f05c0b25-08b4-43e6-96e6-9010e580ae54", "evidence": "Calculation of LTV, acquisition costs, and contribution margin per member.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 13, "frameworkName": "unit-economics-analysis" }, { "matchId": "34cbd31a-0ec9-4d4d-9da9-6c33ca3c5e6b", "evidence": "The slide explicitly calculates revenue and profit adjustments to expose accounting misstatements.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 14, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" }, { "matchId": "eb77aec3-b48a-42f4-9c01-2effba981489", "evidence": "The slide explicitly frames the company as a 'stock promotion' and 'charade' based on insider selling and lack of operational expertise.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.95, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.21+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 15, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "patterns": [] }, "storymakers": null, "score": null, "review": null, "activistThesis": { "tone": "adversarial", "notes": "Classic Muddy Waters text-heavy research note (15p Word-style memo, not a slide deck). Core thesis is ASC 606 accounting critique: EHTH books 3 years of commissions upfront while actual MA churn has spiked to 47%, making the business loss-making on a unit basis. Uses former-employee quotes extensively. Peer references to Expedia/Zillow are management's own framing being turned against them, not MW's benchmarking. Heavy use of CEO/CFO quote contradictions (Flanders on 'no incremental costs', Francis missing cash-flow guidance repeatedly). Closes with insider selling table rather than an explicit target price.", "kpisCited": [ { "detail": "47.0% in 2019 vs. 36.9% in 2017 — skyrocketed after ASC 606 adoption", "metric": "MA churn rate (TTM)" }, { "detail": "-$135 loss on variable costs; -$402 loss including fixed costs (2019)", "metric": "Per-member MA profit" }, { "detail": "Adjusted down $128M or 25% — stated $506.2M vs. adjusted $378.3M", "metric": "2019 revenue overstatement" }, { "detail": "Down $263M — stated $81.4M profit vs. adjusted -$181.5M loss", "metric": "2019 operating profit adjustment" }, { "detail": "EHTH books 3.35 years; Muddy Waters estimates 2.34 years (28.1% LTV overstatement)", "metric": "Remaining MA customer life" }, { "detail": "Stated $1,013; adjusted $728 after life correction; contribution margin -$135", "metric": "Stated vs. adjusted MA LTV" }, { "detail": "$96 per MA member per year ($226 over 2.34 years) that EHTH fails to expense", "metric": "Ongoing retention/service cost" }, { "detail": "$34.9M total; CEO Scott Flanders alone sold $26.0M, 15% of his stake in Jan 2020", "metric": "Insider sales since late 2018" }, { "detail": "~$15M across two campaigns generating >1 billion TV impressions", "metric": "DR TV advertising spend" }, { "detail": "1.2% in 2017, 25.8% in 2018, 88.3% in 2019 — fueled by DR TV", "metric": "MA Approved Applications growth" }, { "detail": "-$71.5M actual vs. -$17M to -$20M February 2019 guidance", "metric": "2019 operating cash burn" } ], "closingAsk": "Recognize EHTH as a stock promotion whose growth rests on aggressive ASC 606 accounting, escalating churn, cash incineration, and heavy insider selling.", "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 19:43:55+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": 123.104095, "promptVersion": null }, "scqaReward": "Corrected figures reveal a -$181M operating loss (vs. $81M reported), -$135 to -$402 loss per MA enrollee, and 25% revenue overstatement — supporting a short thesis against the $116.90 stock price.", "thesisTypes": [ "fraud_exposure" ], "top3Reasons": [ "MA churn has spiked from 36.9% in 2017 to 47% in 2019, invalidating EHTH's 3-year LTV life", "Adjusted unit economics show EHTH loses $135-$402 on every Medicare Advantage enrollee", "2019 revenue is overstated by $128M (25%) under aggressive ASC 606 mark-to-model accounting" ], "scqaSituation": "eHealth is an online Medicare insurance broker that books multi-year commissions upfront under ASC 606, positioning itself to investors as the 'Expedia/Zillow of health insurance.'", "thesisSummary": "Muddy Waters argues eHealth's post-ASC-606 accounting masks a deeply unprofitable Medicare Advantage business. Since 2018, EHTH has driven MA growth by flooding direct-response TV with ads that attract low-income and under-65 disabled enrollees — high-churn cohorts whose true churn has climbed to roughly 47%, versus the ~35% implied by the three-year life baked into EHTH's LTV. Applying a realistic 2.34-year life and allocating real retention and service costs, Muddy Waters calculates a -$135 variable loss per MA member (or -$402 including fixed costs), adjusts 2019 revenue down 25% ($128M) and operating profit down $263M to a -$181M loss. With CEO Scott Flanders selling 15% of his stake in January 2020 and insiders offloading $34.9M since 2019, Muddy Waters views EHTH as a cash-burning stock promotion posing as the 'Expedia of health insurance.'", "primaryDemands": [ "Investors should discount EHTH's stated LTV and revenue, which rely on aggressive ASC 606 persistence assumptions", "Recognize EHTH's Medicare Advantage unit economics as loss-making (-$135 to -$402 per member)", "Question management's narrative of being the 'Expedia/Zillow of health insurance' given skyrocketing churn", "Scrutinize insider selling, particularly CEO Scott Flanders offloading 15% of his stake in January 2020" ], "scqaResolution": "Apply a realistic 2.34-year MA member life, allocate ongoing service and retention costs, and re-expense the inflated commissions that mask true unit economics under EHTH's aggressive ASC 606 application.", "thesisOneLiner": "eHealth books three years of Medicare Advantage commissions upfront while true churn has spiked to 47%; corrected, every MA enrollee loses $135-$402 — a cash-incinerating stock promotion.", "precedentsCited": [], "scqaComplication": "Since 2018, EHTH has grown by flooding direct-response TV with ads that attract low-income and under-65 disabled enrollees whose churn has skyrocketed to 47%, invalidating the 3-year LTV life underpinning reported revenue.", "narrativeInterest": 5, "notableSlidePages": [ 2, 5, 9, 13, 15 ], "peerCompaniesCited": [ "Expedia", "Zillow" ], "valuationFrameworks": [ "other" ], "visualCraftInterest": 2 }, "pitchdeck": { "metadata": null, "profile": null }, "slides": [ { "page": 1, "type": "setup", "title": "Standard legal boilerplate for investment research firm.", "function": "other", "imagePath": "https://imgproxy.kitesheet.com/MnMA7Wy3QRiKWRkrRJI7fHxwe4Cz9GL4TSinS-UyRr0/rs:fit:1200:1200:0/q:82/f:webp/czM6Ly9raXRlc2hlZXQvY29ycHVzL3NsaWRlcy9iNGNkZjA0ZWQwZmIvcDAwMS5qcGc", "rawType": "disclaimer", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "disclaimer", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Disclaimer", "slug": "disclaimer", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-0801-727b-b98a-5ed095aeee78", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "other", "functionCanon": { "name": "Other (fallback)", "slug": "other", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-15e1-75bc-99dc-07732380e2ce", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "sparse", "densityScore": 10, "componentCount": 3, "textChars": 337, "nDataPoints": 0, "notes": "Standard legal boilerplate for investment research firm.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:46.616+00", "seconds": 1.72, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/1", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-1", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.9, "x": 0.05, "y": 0.12 }, "kind": "disclaimer", "text": "These Terms of Use govern current reports published by Muddy Waters Research and supersede any prior Terms of Use for older reports of Muddy Waters Research, which you may download from the Muddy Waters Research's website.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Disclaimer", "slug": "disclaimer", "status": "active", "canonId": "91173477-d91f-4024-bbaf-d4f93e3f82dc", "version": 1, "description": "Legal/cautionary text that occupies most of the body of its slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:46.616+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "b76d5dae-3251-42ed-9a62-292de0b8fc4b", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.75, "w": 0.9, "x": 0.05, "y": 0.16 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "The reports on this website have been prepared by Muddy Waters Capital LLC... [full legal text follows]", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:46.616+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "2d65b171-972f-43b4-b3d3-915d3f077638", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.9, "x": 0.05, "y": 0.12 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Terms of Use", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:46.616+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "2262425e-28a1-4459-a082-1fac11ccb175", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 3, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 1, "name": "Disclaimer and Executive Summary", "beatId": "dde77bb7-5dca-4829-8738-bf5685e58ab4", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": { "name": "Hook", "slug": "hook", "status": "active", "canonId": "019dd9b8-01a6-7328-bff2-b22eb40b3ea5", "version": 1, "description": "The opener — a deliberate move to earn attention before any argument. Used by AIDA, Monroes, Pixar Pitch, Overcoming the Monster." }, "evidence": "The report begins with a disclaimer and executive summary, setting the tone for the rest of the report", "position": 0, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [], "thumbSrc": "https://imgproxy.kitesheet.com/3NLMcKVTUvrZiHBfHryypIMlzwI5vuAirMVPFE4NswU/rs:fit:480:480:0/q:78/f:webp/czM6Ly9raXRlc2hlZXQvY29ycHVzL3NsaWRlcy9iNGNkZjA0ZWQwZmIvcDAwMS5qcGc", "imagePathAlt": "https://imgproxy.kitesheet.com/CdylPHqWs_oRiwNyOTTJXQ7hx8OcbsZ5pLCSIVTvpug/rs:fit:1200:1200:0/q:82/f:webp/czM6Ly9raXRlc2hlZXQvY29ycHVzL3NsaWRlcy9iNGNkZjA0ZWQwZmIvcDAwMS5wbmc", "thumbSrcAlt": "https://imgproxy.kitesheet.com/gjmdz1a9WWvsGsbzivDt65p0JcG_8ucLLuHrjxC4JTc/rs:fit:480:480:0/q:78/f:webp/czM6Ly9raXRlc2hlZXQvY29ycHVzL3NsaWRlcy9iNGNkZjA0ZWQwZmIvcDAwMS5wbmc" }, { "page": 2, "type": "setup", "title": "This is a classic short-seller thesis summary slide, often referred to as a 'bear case' summary.", "function": "summarize", "rawType": "executive_summary", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "executive_summary", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Executive summary", "slug": "executive_summary", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-06be-73ff-81b3-f99fe7f0025e", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "summarize", "functionCanon": { "name": "Summarize", "slug": "summarize", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-1541-704f-b86f-bf7b75056373", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "balanced", "densityScore": 27, "componentCount": 4, "textChars": 665, "nDataPoints": 10, "notes": "This is a classic short-seller thesis summary slide, often referred to as a 'bear case' summary.", "elementsJson": [ "bullet_list", "data_table" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.139+00", "seconds": 3.229, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/2", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-2", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "EHTH management is, in our view, running a massive stock promotion.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b6-7431-a284-e20e33458334", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.6, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.33 }, "kind": "list", "text": "EHTH's highly aggressive accounting masks what we believe is a significantly unprofitable business. We adjust 2019 revenue down by $128 million or 25%. EHTH's persistence assumptions in its LTV model seem highly aggressive. Key driver of growth is Direct Response television advertising. EHTH has been incinerating cash. EHTH management is running a massive stock promotion.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "List", "slug": "list", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f94b-779b-a53b-fd4904a5f4d2", "version": 1, "description": "Bullet or numbered list." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Bullet list", "slug": "bullet", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fc98-7169-a083-5cab805076ca", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "bullet", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.139+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "b8250c84-4013-479e-b05e-df302eaf43fc", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "operating loss: -$181 million", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b6-7431-a284-e5be5c82b4a3", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.2, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.09 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Report Date: April 8, 2020; Company: eHealth Inc.; Ticker: EHTH US; Industry: Insurance; Stock Price: $116.90; Market Cap: $3.0 billion; Float: 94.4%; Average Daily Volume (30-day): $96.4 million", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.139+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "23e32b9c-dff3-4210-ba6f-70712489de94", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [ { "tool": { "name": "Executive summary", "slug": "executive-summary", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-4b63-72d5-9734-da757d91ca61", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "A condensed view of the entire argument on a single slide / block.", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "slide", "agents": null, "matchId": "b61d2fe9-12d7-4a12-b0be-bc8c7a6e93fa", "evidence": "type: executive_summary", "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-17 03:55:28.626868+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 2, "whyItWorks": null, "antipattern": null, "cardinality": "common", "narrativePurpose": null } ], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "f00b374b-4dbe-4332-80e6-659d5dad7af3", "evidence": "The slide explicitly outlines allegations of aggressive accounting, misleading management, and value destruction.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.139+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 2, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 3, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 1, "name": "Disclaimer and Executive Summary", "beatId": "dde77bb7-5dca-4829-8738-bf5685e58ab4", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": { "name": "Hook", "slug": "hook", "status": "active", "canonId": "019dd9b8-01a6-7328-bff2-b22eb40b3ea5", "version": 1, "description": "The opener — a deliberate move to earn attention before any argument. Used by AIDA, Monroes, Pixar Pitch, Overcoming the Monster." }, "evidence": "The report begins with a disclaimer and executive summary, setting the tone for the rest of the report", "position": 0, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [], "locked": true }, { "page": 3, "type": "setup", "title": "The slide serves as a critical narrative piece in a research report, linking accounting changes to management behavior and operational metrics.", "function": "summarize", "rawType": "executive_summary", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "executive_summary", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Executive summary", "slug": "executive_summary", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-06be-73ff-81b3-f99fe7f0025e", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "summarize", "functionCanon": { "name": "Summarize", "slug": "summarize", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-1541-704f-b86f-bf7b75056373", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "balanced", "densityScore": 34, "componentCount": 6, "textChars": 597, "nDataPoints": 6, "notes": "The slide serves as a critical narrative piece in a research report, linking accounting changes to management behavior and operational metrics.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "footnote" ], "confidence": 0.95, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:47.872+00", "seconds": 2.765, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/3", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-3", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "We think it reasonable to assume EHTH’s new leaders, Messrs. Flanders and Francis, knew of the impending standard when they took over in mid-2016.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-37342e910a1b", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "churn rate: 47%", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-38fddced295e", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.7, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.14 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "There are three years that explain the problems with EHTH – 2014, 2016, and 2018. The foundation for the promotion was laid in 2014 when FASB codified ASC 606...", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:47.872+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "142e90fc-4a82-4c7b-89f0-213a321c0769", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.1, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.8 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "1 ASC 606 technically went into effect for fiscal years beginning on or after December 15, 2017. See https://www.fasb.org/jsp/FASB/FASBContent_C/CompletedProjectPage&cid=1175805486538", "attrs": { "numbered": true }, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:47.872+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "3a0702dd-e08f-4870-a6df-94061e67de03", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.4, "x": 0.3, "y": 0.71 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "Table 1: eHealth Medicare Advantage Churn", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:47.872+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "462769ed-96b2-4f71-8fb6-f1040f3dc4ba", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.09 }, "kind": "title", "text": "2014 – The Year that Birthed EHTH’s Stock Promotion", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:47.872+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "8c958112-6065-4a1c-a2aa-13b52cfba6f9", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [ { "tool": { "name": "Executive summary", "slug": "executive-summary", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-4b63-72d5-9734-da757d91ca61", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "A condensed view of the entire argument on a single slide / block.", "familyLabel": null, "categoryName": null, "categorySlug": null }, "agent": null, "layer": "slide", "agents": null, "matchId": "f7bafb9f-9207-41db-ba71-f37ac71356da", "evidence": "type: executive_summary", "pageRefs": null, "priority": null, "whenToUse": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-17 03:55:28.690759+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 3, "whyItWorks": null, "antipattern": null, "cardinality": "common", "narrativePurpose": null } ], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "c001c9c5-6148-49e4-920b-3c380376c91e", "evidence": "The text explicitly argues that management manipulated business operations to exploit accounting standards (ASC 606) for stock promotion.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:47.872+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 3, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 3, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 1, "name": "Disclaimer and Executive Summary", "beatId": "dde77bb7-5dca-4829-8738-bf5685e58ab4", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": { "name": "Hook", "slug": "hook", "status": "active", "canonId": "019dd9b8-01a6-7328-bff2-b22eb40b3ea5", "version": 1, "description": "The opener — a deliberate move to earn attention before any argument. Used by AIDA, Monroes, Pixar Pitch, Overcoming the Monster." }, "evidence": "The report begins with a disclaimer and executive summary, setting the tone for the rest of the report", "position": 0, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [], "locked": true }, { "page": 4, "type": "tension", "title": "Includes a table showing eHealth Medicare Advantage Churn metrics from FY16 to FY19.", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "villain_critique", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "villain_critique", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Villain critique", "slug": "villain_critique", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-10bc-7136-bf20-09de59d17447", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "dense", "densityScore": 58, "componentCount": 8, "textChars": 793, "nDataPoints": 85, "notes": "Includes a table showing eHealth Medicare Advantage Churn metrics from FY16 to FY19.", "elementsJson": [ "headline_text", "data_table", "paragraph", "bullet_list", "footnote" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "seconds": 7.321, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/4", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-4", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "We believe that EHTH uses an overly optimistic MA member persistence assumption, which has a material impact on profitability (or lack thereof) of an enrollee.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b6-7431-a284-c3a5fd9ff2e7", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.055, "w": 0.55, "x": 0.147, "y": 0.305 }, "kind": "list", "text": "Three years for MA plans; Five years for Medicare Part D prescription drug plans; Five years for Medicare Supplement plans", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "List", "slug": "list", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f94b-779b-a53b-fd4904a5f4d2", "version": 1, "description": "Bullet or numbered list." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Bullet list", "slug": "bullet", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fc98-7169-a083-5cab805076ca", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "bullet", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "17267029-443f-4f2d-ad37-17bbecc2f0bf", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "Churn % (TTM): 47%", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b6-7431-a284-c6dfcd75a16d", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.032, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.253 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "The Company estimates member persistence in order to calculate its health insurance plan LTVs. Among these estimates are:", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "63a6fe9c-7b3e-48fa-b76e-8cb593c8fdfb", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.35, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.378 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "We believe that EHTH uses an overly optimistic MA member persistence assumption... We believe the combination of using a three-year life and then booking additional commission revenue for tail customers overstates expected future cash collections.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "b2171aae-3ddb-43a8-9c98-7eaac81fe07c", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.25, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.878 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "EHTH 2019 10-K, p. 66; November 2019 presentation, p. 33.", "attrs": { "numbered": true }, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "dcdb9d4f-09b2-4598-8b23-0c7a51dd53c4", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.075, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.115 }, "kind": "table", "text": "eHealth Medicare Advantage Churn table", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "2d6e22be-0fe0-4ee5-9d67-9ee366d70c71", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.018, "w": 0.305, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.218 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Aggressive LTV Life Assumptions", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "c8586ffc-5672-4d9d-b4eb-a60c6763040a", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "9fdb1dd6-48cd-4059-a92e-84d337962a5c", "evidence": "Critique of manipulated methodology and overstatement of revenue.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.433+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 4, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 7, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 4, "name": "Critique of EHTH's Business Practices", "beatId": "a7d2bd7d-d3e2-4d86-8aa9-29ef2dc6e3b2", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report critiques EHTH's business practices, including its overly optimistic member persistence assumptions", "position": 1, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 7, "from": 4, "loop": { "name": "06_zoom_in", "slug": "06-zoom-in", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Technical deep-dives, case studies, detailed analysis", "canonId": "019dd956-6846-74db-82be-dff5b058b072", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Big Picture -> Key Area of Focus -> Specific Detail -> Implication", "description": "Start broad, then progressively focus on specific details that prove your point", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "69c5fb1b-d8a2-4668-b25e-a5d752abdd93", "evidence": "The report zooms in on EHTH's business practices and financials, critiquing its overly optimistic assumptions", "position": 0, "objective": "What are EHTH's business practices and financials?", "confidence": 0.8, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.899042+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 5, "type": "analysis", "title": "The slide explains the sensitivity of LTV calculations to churn assumptions and provides a methodology for calculating implied churn.", "function": "analyze_data", "rawType": "appendix_methodology", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "appendix_methodology", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Appendix methodology", "slug": "appendix_methodology", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-07d9-726c-8599-167f2d2ffaa7", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "analyze_data", "functionCanon": { "name": "Analyze data", "slug": "analyze_data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-1590-7413-8c82-cc218cff40b4", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "dense", "densityScore": 62, "componentCount": 9, "textChars": 644, "nDataPoints": 80, "notes": "The slide explains the sensitivity of LTV calculations to churn assumptions and provides a methodology for calculating implied churn.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "data_table", "line_chart", "footnote" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "seconds": 2.866, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/5", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-5", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "Over the past two years, MA implied churn has steadily worsened to 47%, which implies a life of only 2.1 years.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b6-7431-a285-2d5374e29c0f", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.35, "w": 0.6, "x": 0.2, "y": 0.505 }, "kind": "chart", "text": "Line chart showing the trend of eHealth Medicare Advantage Churn from 4Q16 to 4Q19.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Chart", "slug": "chart", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9a0-76ef-adc6-0b859109d1f8", "version": 1, "description": "Quantitative chart." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Line chart", "slug": "line", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-ff62-778f-8f6c-a952ceae8677", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "line", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "e96e53a4-aaf8-4896-bc06-015826e67508", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.08, "x": 0.38, "y": 0.615 }, "kind": "legend", "text": "ASC 606 Adoption", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Legend", "slug": "legend", "status": "active", "canonId": "31361933-3d22-4c70-bbad-0801e9fffc0c", "version": 1, "description": "Color/symbol decoder placed adjacent to a chart or diagram." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "ff8f064d-4a3d-4e7d-9e0d-fe42b28bec39", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "churn rate: 47%", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:44+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b6-7431-a285-30255d2ea07b", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.06, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.145 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "The LTVs are highly sensitive to even small changes in the persistence assumption. Based on the 47.0% implied churn in 2019 MA members, the implied life is 2.1 years.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "4ab1c90f-7ca6-4502-8bdb-7983017f6722", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.65, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.252 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "To calculate the implied churn rates for each quarter, we use the following formula:", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "831ccbdf-9e55-4879-a712-671bc5d9d8a5", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.15, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.895 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "EHTH 2019 10-K, p. 73", "attrs": { "numbered": true }, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "3d1a22bc-bf13-462c-b889-8ca5d3a2b9de", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.08, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.41 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Table showing Beginning, Approved Applications, Implied Churn, Ending, and Churn % (TTM) from FY16 to FY19.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "cb22f6eb-f472-4add-8ec8-e15696b31286", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.36, "x": 0.32, "y": 0.383 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Table 2: eHealth Medicare Advantage Churn", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.091+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "3810186f-0dad-4092-a277-37749a200993", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 7, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 4, "name": "Critique of EHTH's Business Practices", "beatId": "a7d2bd7d-d3e2-4d86-8aa9-29ef2dc6e3b2", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report critiques EHTH's business practices, including its overly optimistic member persistence assumptions", "position": 1, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 7, "from": 4, "loop": { "name": "06_zoom_in", "slug": "06-zoom-in", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Technical deep-dives, case studies, detailed analysis", "canonId": "019dd956-6846-74db-82be-dff5b058b072", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Big Picture -> Key Area of Focus -> Specific Detail -> Implication", "description": "Start broad, then progressively focus on specific details that prove your point", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "69c5fb1b-d8a2-4668-b25e-a5d752abdd93", "evidence": "The report zooms in on EHTH's business practices and financials, critiquing its overly optimistic assumptions", "position": 0, "objective": "What are EHTH's business practices and financials?", "confidence": 0.8, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.899042+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 6, "type": "tension", "title": "The slide uses tables to demonstrate that eHealth's churn assumptions imply unrealistically long customer lives, leading to an overstated commissions receivable", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "expose_contradiction", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "expose_contradiction", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-124c-75aa-984a-0a3d0d8fc8df", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "overcrowded", "densityScore": 87, "componentCount": 11, "textChars": 1485, "nDataPoints": 100, "notes": "The slide uses tables to demonstrate that eHealth's churn assumptions imply unrealistically long customer lives, leading to an overstated commissions receivable balance.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "data_table", "comparison_table" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "seconds": 3.933, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/6", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-6", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "The net effect of this extra year of customer life on the books is that we estimate EHTH’s constrained LTV for MA members is overstated by 28.2%.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:45+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-8ead85b20247", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "Remaining Customer Life: 28.2%", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:45+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-9158bd3f6c8b", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.4, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.85 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "Apparently Sally Struthers Was Unavailable", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "155780fb-d90e-430e-ac1d-1cbd8e7e3dff", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.04, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.09 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "EHTH’s persistence assumptions for Medicare Supplement and Medicare Part D also look highly aggressive relative to churn from the 2018 and 2019 cohorts. For Medicare Supplement, EHTH churn implies a life of 4.3 years.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "399b021f-cd8a-43b3-9791-443c8669ea7b", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.09, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.57 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "In MA, for example, we calculate that EHTH uses 3.35 years of remaining life. This means that EHTH assumes its customers’ total lives are well above 3.35 years, due to the fact that the company’s book of business has already aged. We, on the other hand, model remaining life of 2.34 years, which is the mean of the implied lives of 2017 through 2019 MA cohort members. The net effect of this extra year of customer life on the books is that we estimate EHTH’s constrained LTV for MA members is overstated by 28.2%.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "7eea465e-e5fe-4bf5-bbb1-290d5da02de6", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.06, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.45 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "We believe EHTH has taken advantage of its reliance on two statistical models, one for new members and one for aged members. As a result, we believe that the company significantly overstates the remaining customer life on its books in order to arrive at its $589 million commissions receivable balance.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "927db1dd-b99d-4932-b1a6-d18b3c890360", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.58, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.29 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "For Medicare Part D, EHTH churn indicates a life of 4.1 years.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "f73bc612-3485-454b-8dc6-4389fe0814c9", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.11, "w": 0.58, "x": 0.21, "y": 0.16 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Table 3: eHealth Medicare Supplement Churn", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "70aa1a65-73e4-4318-a17c-fd3605cdb0bc", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.11, "w": 0.48, "x": 0.26, "y": 0.69 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Table 5: Remaining Customer Life Estimate", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "dc5ae91a-7e52-4cc0-8f96-2f35b17a389a", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.11, "w": 0.58, "x": 0.21, "y": 0.33 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Table 4: eHealth Medicare Part D Churn", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "e0d57ec9-397b-4aa2-bc49-bcf91b36efb4", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.5, "x": 0.25, "y": 0.53 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Remaining Life = Total Life – Existing Customer Life", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Subtitle", "slug": "subtitle", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb09-739d-900c-815b0d9ac526", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "subtitle", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.771+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "75c463d4-d2ec-4e2c-b438-2de194aaba64", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 7, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 4, "name": "Critique of EHTH's Business Practices", "beatId": "a7d2bd7d-d3e2-4d86-8aa9-29ef2dc6e3b2", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report critiques EHTH's business practices, including its overly optimistic member persistence assumptions", "position": 1, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 7, "from": 4, "loop": { "name": "06_zoom_in", "slug": "06-zoom-in", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Technical deep-dives, case studies, detailed analysis", "canonId": "019dd956-6846-74db-82be-dff5b058b072", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Big Picture -> Key Area of Focus -> Specific Detail -> Implication", "description": "Start broad, then progressively focus on specific details that prove your point", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "69c5fb1b-d8a2-4668-b25e-a5d752abdd93", "evidence": "The report zooms in on EHTH's business practices and financials, critiquing its overly optimistic assumptions", "position": 0, "objective": "What are EHTH's business practices and financials?", "confidence": 0.8, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.899042+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 7, "type": "tension", "title": "The slide uses expert testimony to argue that the company's growth strategy relies on low-loyalty customers, creating a churn-heavy business model.", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "quote_slide", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "quote_slide", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Quote slide", "slug": "quote_slide", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-098e-7555-a9fd-4f0af7e80bc2", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "dense", "densityScore": 50, "componentCount": 6, "textChars": 1916, "nDataPoints": 0, "notes": "The slide uses expert testimony to argue that the company's growth strategy relies on low-loyalty customers, creating a churn-heavy business model.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "quote_block", "footnote" ], "confidence": 0.95, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.562+00", "seconds": 2.487, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/7", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-7", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "We believe the backbone of EHTH’s growth in MA Accepted Applications in 2018 and 2019 was a high-churn demographic that responds to DR advertising.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:45+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-de7086f00507", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.15, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.1 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "We believe the backbone of EHTH's growth in MA Accepted Applications in 2018 and 2019 was a high-churn demographic that responds to DR advertising. Our research made clear that two demographics have particularly high churn in the MA space: Low income enrollees and younger than 65 members who qualify for Medicare because of disability.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.562+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "e36c7d11-751a-40fa-8c37-fbe15430f3ba", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.2, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.58 }, "kind": "quote", "text": "...Yeah, I would say the way to answer that question [about whether customer lives are trending down], you are what you eat and that meaning whatever their marketing channels are there will give you an indication of the LTV.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Testimonial", "slug": "testimonial", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fc21-71b6-9ac3-8266a64945e8", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "testimonial", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.562+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "038144c4-193c-4575-b5a9-39bd19703030", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.3, "w": 0.8, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.28 }, "kind": "quote", "text": "It's sort of the dredges of advertising. [EHTH] buy very cheap inventory on cable TV... that tend to just attract an older demographic and demographic that tends to be watching like 10 hours of TV a day, makes less than $25,000 a year.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Testimonial", "slug": "testimonial", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fc21-71b6-9ac3-8266a64945e8", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "testimonial", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.562+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "1a830b5b-f5fc-44c0-b05f-1c419470b361", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "quote", "text": "It’s sort of the dredges of advertising. [EHTH] buy very cheap inventory on cable TV... that tend to just attract an older demographic and demographic that tends to be watching like 10 hours of TV a day, makes less than $25,000 a year. That’s where they get their enormous, through that channel. — EHTH Former Executive B. \n\nYeah, I would say the way to answer that question [about whether customer lives are trending down], you are what you eat and that meaning whatever their marketing channels are there will give you an indication of the LTV. — EHTH Former Executive B. \n\nAnd then whenever you had DR TV and things like that you could drive that mix up like fifty percent of under sixty-five which is not good, desirable mix that the carriers wanted. They usually wanted something under thirty percent or something like that... We started TV probably the last couple of years I was there. — EHTH Former Executive A.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": { "name": "Authority citation", "slug": "authority-citation", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-49ae-7557-89ad-3fca70469b45", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Quoting an authority figure, study, or precedent to lend weight.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:45+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-e2cc33b395ec", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.05, "w": 0.3, "x": 0.1, "y": 0.88 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "10 EHTH Former Executive B. 11 EHTH Former Executive A.", "attrs": { "numbered": true }, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.562+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "68a7c03b-b5c1-4b21-b717-f71b85bcf286", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "802cdb0c-ff74-47ee-abde-d20114ecf386", "evidence": "Use of former executive quotes to validate the thesis on churn.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:48.562+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 7, "frameworkName": "authority-citation" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 7, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 4, "name": "Critique of EHTH's Business Practices", "beatId": "a7d2bd7d-d3e2-4d86-8aa9-29ef2dc6e3b2", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report critiques EHTH's business practices, including its overly optimistic member persistence assumptions", "position": 1, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 7, "from": 4, "loop": { "name": "06_zoom_in", "slug": "06-zoom-in", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Technical deep-dives, case studies, detailed analysis", "canonId": "019dd956-6846-74db-82be-dff5b058b072", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Big Picture -> Key Area of Focus -> Specific Detail -> Implication", "description": "Start broad, then progressively focus on specific details that prove your point", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "69c5fb1b-d8a2-4668-b25e-a5d752abdd93", "evidence": "The report zooms in on EHTH's business practices and financials, critiquing its overly optimistic assumptions", "position": 0, "objective": "What are EHTH's business practices and financials?", "confidence": 0.8, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.899042+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 8, "type": "tension", "title": "The slide includes a screenshot of an EHTH TV advertisement and references footnotes 12 and 13.", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "expose_contradiction", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "expose_contradiction", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-124c-75aa-984a-0a3d0d8fc8df", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "balanced", "densityScore": 49, "componentCount": 7, "textChars": 944, "nDataPoints": 2, "notes": "The slide includes a screenshot of an EHTH TV advertisement and references footnotes 12 and 13.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "screenshot", "footnote" ], "confidence": 0.95, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.366+00", "seconds": 6.281, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/8", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-8", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "The denominator used to calculate churn is actually greater than the Estimated Ending Membership in the two most recent quarters!", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:45+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-c712576f57cb", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.35, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.17 }, "kind": "image", "text": "Screenshot of EHTH TV advertisement", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Image", "slug": "image", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f978-701f-a720-51d029d769e7", "version": 1, "description": "Photo, illustration, screenshot or icon." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Screenshot", "slug": "screenshot", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fd87-7509-8391-3d79fb339379", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "screenshot", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.366+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "15643f91-6916-4eeb-8313-eecb606211b5", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.05, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.09 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "An advertising measurement company estimates that EHTH has spent approximately $15 million across two TV ad campaigns that have generated in excess of one billion TV impressions.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.366+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "41ae3373-1ee8-4b09-b73c-c56883af1d50", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.07, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.76 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "Below is a slide from the most recent investor presentation showing lower churn metrics seven to 10 percentage points lower than we calculate. The denominator used to calculate churn is actually greater than the Estimated Ending Membership in the two most recent quarters!", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.366+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "f3c87990-58a9-41d8-b4d5-689301c04f5c", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.07, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.63 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "We see EHTH as taking pains to pull the wool over investors' eyes with respect to recent churn rates. EHTH has published its own churn rates, which in our view materially understate the churn.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.366+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "f7a0d5f3-263b-4230-9a32-dfde100954fd", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.6, "x": 0.2, "y": 0.55 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "Source: https://www.ispot.tv/ad/I8u0/ehealthinsurance-services-all-in-one-medicare-coverage", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.366+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "9e125dd8-9b8a-4c84-a7b9-fa9bbc80526e", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.5, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.6 }, "kind": "title", "text": "EHTH Deliberately Obscures the Increasing Churn", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Action title", "slug": "action-title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb31-734c-a0f5-a3935b73135d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "action-title", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.366+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "8555b5c2-c919-4aea-90cd-e928c843e0fb", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 11, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 8, "name": "Exposure of EHTH's Contradictions", "beatId": "28e1c45d-1e7d-4f4d-9e61-ac306c4fa834", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, including its deliberate obscuring of increasing churn rates", "position": 2, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 11, "from": 8, "loop": { "name": "10_iceberg", "slug": "10-iceberg", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Consulting, complex problem solving, organizational change", "canonId": "019dd956-69f4-738c-852a-643798da0899", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Symptom (Visible) -> The System (Hidden) -> The Root Cause", "description": "Reveal that the visible problem is merely a symptom of a deeper root cause", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "38a6f789-a22a-4dbe-9534-a7c98a2ea885", "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, revealing the iceberg beneath the surface", "position": 1, "objective": "What are the implications of EHTH's contradictions?", "confidence": 0.7, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.936524+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 9, "type": "tension", "title": "Includes a detailed table of membership metrics and a critique of the churn formula.", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "expose_contradiction", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "expose_contradiction", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-124c-75aa-984a-0a3d0d8fc8df", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "dense", "densityScore": 73, "componentCount": 9, "textChars": 1151, "nDataPoints": 48, "notes": "Includes a detailed table of membership metrics and a critique of the churn formula.", "elementsJson": [ "headline_text", "data_table", "paragraph", "footnote" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "seconds": 3.098, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/9", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-9", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "EHTH uses a misleading large customer pool as the denominator. The company adds New Paying Members to Estimated Members, which does not make sense, as it ignores the customers dropping out over the course of the quarter.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:45+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-aa854cd14330", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "Trailing Twelve Month Member Turnover Rate: 34%", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:45+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bc-afe7b14a4cb2", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.05, "w": 0.75, "x": 0.12, "y": 0.86 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "Against a constrained MA LTV of $728, we apply total costs of $863 to arrive at a 2019 per member loss of -$135.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "134a149c-9656-417a-a247-eaf45501a5a6", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.1, "w": 0.75, "x": 0.12, "y": 0.35 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "EHTH also aggressively states the numerator. EHTH defines churn as follows: Initial Estimated Members + New Paying Members (Est.) - Final Estimated Members / Average TTM Estimated Members + New Paying Members (Est.)", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "1f31499c-b171-4c3a-b580-f81608798e69", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.15, "w": 0.75, "x": 0.12, "y": 0.58 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "EHTH uses a misleadingly large customer pool as the denominator. The company adds New Paying Members to Estimated Members, which does not make sense, as it ignores the customers dropping out over the course of the quarter.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "491d7a49-c5b1-4c1c-bac9-3825449311e0", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.1, "w": 0.75, "x": 0.12, "y": 0.45 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "The numerator EHTH uses to calculate churn, in our view, is aggressive. EHTH is double-dipping by constraining the model for applicants who it estimates do not turn into paying members.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "f555bfad-1476-4b9b-a76f-fbd41baec380", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.15, "w": 0.65, "x": 0.12, "y": 0.16 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Table showing membership metrics from Q4 18 to Q3 19", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "ecf5e27a-32b5-4e74-ba91-685fa7506a97", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.4, "x": 0.12, "y": 0.82 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Costs That Make MA Members Unprofitable", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "2c94b0b6-d510-487a-856b-375df27369bc", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.04, "w": 0.45, "x": 0.12, "y": 0.09 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Medicare Advantage Plan Member Turnover Trend Since Q4 2018", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "ddcd439b-ee49-449e-ac11-866ac28b5662", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "7c84452b-ebeb-45e6-bc79-9d959d8a1aa5", "evidence": "Critique of accounting methodology and churn calculation", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.464+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 9, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 11, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 8, "name": "Exposure of EHTH's Contradictions", "beatId": "28e1c45d-1e7d-4f4d-9e61-ac306c4fa834", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, including its deliberate obscuring of increasing churn rates", "position": 2, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 11, "from": 8, "loop": { "name": "10_iceberg", "slug": "10-iceberg", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Consulting, complex problem solving, organizational change", "canonId": "019dd956-69f4-738c-852a-643798da0899", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Symptom (Visible) -> The System (Hidden) -> The Root Cause", "description": "Reveal that the visible problem is merely a symptom of a deeper root cause", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "38a6f789-a22a-4dbe-9534-a7c98a2ea885", "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, revealing the iceberg beneath the surface", "position": 1, "objective": "What are the implications of EHTH's contradictions?", "confidence": 0.7, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.936524+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 10, "type": "analysis", "title": "The slide argues that EHTH ignores ongoing service costs to justify booking multi-year commissions upfront.", "function": "analyze_data", "rawType": "appendix_data", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "appendix_data", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Appendix data", "slug": "appendix_data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-078a-745b-9ee4-c15f2f539acd", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "analyze_data", "functionCanon": { "name": "Analyze data", "slug": "analyze_data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-1590-7413-8c82-cc218cff40b4", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "dense", "densityScore": 74, "componentCount": 10, "textChars": 994, "nDataPoints": 24, "notes": "The slide argues that EHTH ignores ongoing service costs to justify booking multi-year commissions upfront.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "data_table", "footnote" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "seconds": 12.405, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/10", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-10", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "The crux of EHTH's application of ASC 606 is that EHTH books multiple years of commission revenue by claiming that no further performance on its part is necessary in order to collect these commissions.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-20f9a6a8c534", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "Ongoing Expenses: $51.3", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-28e244de5bc1", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.056, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.684 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "The crux of EHTH's application of ASC 606 is that EHTH books multiple years of commission revenue by claiming that no further performance on its part is necessary in order to collect these commissions.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "0883d743-435f-47cf-ab5f-b94370e4ded7", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.056, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.145 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "We estimate that EHTH has ongoing costs of service and retention of $96 per MA member per year, which includes commissions paid to partners.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "7d648a71-55a0-4601-8623-7aa06fcc7047", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.028, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.093 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "service or act to retain existing customers is central to EHTH's improper application of ASC 606.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "c25287ba-61a1-42cd-af49-0b5f151e6057", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.028, "w": 0.647, "x": 0.176, "y": 0.815 }, "kind": "quote", "text": "the approval of an application from health insurance carriers, which we define as our customers.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Pull quote", "slug": "pull-quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fbf9-76fe-97e1-a0b7540445c9", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "pull-quote", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "a68963a0-ef3c-41f2-85b1-edb3614692a5", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "quote", "text": "\"the approval of an application from health insurance carriers, which we define as our customers.\" — EHTH 2019 10-K, p. 80", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": { "name": "Authority citation", "slug": "authority-citation", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-49ae-7557-89ad-3fca70469b45", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Quoting an authority figure, study, or precedent to lend weight.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-24951a1ea9e9", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.145, "w": 0.446, "x": 0.277, "y": 0.377 }, "kind": "table", "text": "eHealth Ongoing Expenses table", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "5caa288e-13d8-41d4-b409-57a77116b1f5", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.015, "w": 0.315, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.652 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Ongoing Costs = Ongoing Performance", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Action title", "slug": "action-title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb31-734c-a0f5-a3935b73135d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "action-title", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "9c3cfe30-7ba0-440e-961b-a3a972da0d3f", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.012, "w": 0.404, "x": 0.298, "y": 0.355 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Table 6: Retention and Service Expense Allocation", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "49b765f4-3c30-4954-a0f3-a0a39aa838a3", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "85b4aa3b-3cf6-4dd0-bea6-6955fe9b7ece", "evidence": "Argues that company accounting ignores real costs to inflate revenue recognition.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:58.874+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 10, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 11, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 8, "name": "Exposure of EHTH's Contradictions", "beatId": "28e1c45d-1e7d-4f4d-9e61-ac306c4fa834", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, including its deliberate obscuring of increasing churn rates", "position": 2, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 11, "from": 8, "loop": { "name": "10_iceberg", "slug": "10-iceberg", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Consulting, complex problem solving, organizational change", "canonId": "019dd956-69f4-738c-852a-643798da0899", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Symptom (Visible) -> The System (Hidden) -> The Root Cause", "description": "Reveal that the visible problem is merely a symptom of a deeper root cause", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "38a6f789-a22a-4dbe-9534-a7c98a2ea885", "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, revealing the iceberg beneath the surface", "position": 1, "objective": "What are the implications of EHTH's contradictions?", "confidence": 0.7, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.936524+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 11, "type": "tension", "title": "The slide uses direct quotes from earnings calls to highlight management's alleged dishonesty regarding operational costs.", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "expose_contradiction", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "expose_contradiction", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-124c-75aa-984a-0a3d0d8fc8df", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "overcrowded", "densityScore": 78, "componentCount": 9, "textChars": 1892, "nDataPoints": 1, "notes": "The slide uses direct quotes from earnings calls to highlight management's alleged dishonesty regarding operational costs.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "quote_block", "footnote" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "seconds": 7.599, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/11", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-11", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "We view these statements as disingenuous because customers are not obligated to renew their policies.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-0a026992efbd", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.055, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.115 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "EHTH wants to have its cake and eat it too. On the commission side, it recognizes commissions that it says are probable. It fails to take service and retention into account because they are not legal obligations. Management actively misleads investors about the need for further service:", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "27165dfe-9f5d-407f-9432-001d334303f5", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.035, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.705 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "Former EHTH executives also dispute management's notion, stating or agreeing that ongoing retention and service takes resources and costs average $50 to $100 per MA member per year.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "5136db75-d020-4599-ac10-fa376bf2bea7", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.045, "w": 0.764, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.645 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "We view these statements as disingenuous because customers are not obligated to renew their policies. EHTH has to fight to retain business because the industry is highly competitive, and plans change regularly.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "988d681c-86ab-485a-8ea3-f97965901ee9", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.185, "w": 0.737, "x": 0.145, "y": 0.345 }, "kind": "quote", "text": "And the opportunities for us to significantly improve retention rates in that 90-day period post-sale are both substantial and reflect a lot of near-term opportunity that we are very much focused on at the moment. No incremental costs associated with that kind of opportunity...", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Pull quote", "slug": "pull-quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fbf9-76fe-97e1-a0b7540445c9", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "pull-quote", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "384ec1d3-c741-4c5c-9dc5-c0d8ce6e479c", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.055, "w": 0.737, "x": 0.145, "y": 0.181 }, "kind": "quote", "text": "The costs attached to each of the receivable balances have essentially been absorbed as we generate the revenue in any particular quarter. So as the cash comes in, there is no additional cost attached to that.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Pull quote", "slug": "pull-quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fbf9-76fe-97e1-a0b7540445c9", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "pull-quote", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "88b29611-7c40-475b-9293-660217123f9a", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.085, "w": 0.737, "x": 0.145, "y": 0.765 }, "kind": "quote", "text": "And, especially with Medicare enrollments season and sign up period... there is a very high chance that that person could get signed up by another broker or even by the carrier. And, switch them off of your broker record.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Pull quote", "slug": "pull-quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fbf9-76fe-97e1-a0b7540445c9", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "pull-quote", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "a2affaf6-9eff-4742-86b3-21423f7da5c6", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "quote", "text": "\"The costs attached to each of the receivable balances have essentially been absorbed as we generate the revenue in any particular quarter. So as the cash comes in, there is no additional cost attached to that. And the reason that those receivables are there is because there is no meaningful service component attached to them either.\" — Scott Flanders Q1 2018 Earnings Call", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": { "name": "Authority citation", "slug": "authority-citation", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-49ae-7557-89ad-3fca70469b45", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Quoting an authority figure, study, or precedent to lend weight.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-0e6c3a8a31e1", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.25, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.895 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "15 EHTH Q2 2018 Earnings Call.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "6404d57e-06b7-4107-973f-316769fbb3b6", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "b0179c54-5f5c-47a1-af75-e3bda5cd66f8", "evidence": "The slide explicitly frames management statements as 'disingenuous' and 'misleading' to expose potential financial misrepresentation.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:54.092+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 11, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 11, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 8, "name": "Exposure of EHTH's Contradictions", "beatId": "28e1c45d-1e7d-4f4d-9e61-ac306c4fa834", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, including its deliberate obscuring of increasing churn rates", "position": 2, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 }, { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 11, "from": 8, "loop": { "name": "10_iceberg", "slug": "10-iceberg", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Consulting, complex problem solving, organizational change", "canonId": "019dd956-69f4-738c-852a-643798da0899", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Symptom (Visible) -> The System (Hidden) -> The Root Cause", "description": "Reveal that the visible problem is merely a symptom of a deeper root cause", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "38a6f789-a22a-4dbe-9534-a7c98a2ea885", "evidence": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, revealing the iceberg beneath the surface", "position": 1, "objective": "What are the implications of EHTH's contradictions?", "confidence": 0.7, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.936524+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 12, "type": "analysis", "title": "Contains detailed footnotes referencing former executive interviews and methodology for calculating revenue-sharing obligations.", "function": "analyze_data", "rawType": "appendix_data", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "appendix_data", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Appendix data", "slug": "appendix_data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-078a-745b-9ee4-c15f2f539acd", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "analyze_data", "functionCanon": { "name": "Analyze data", "slug": "analyze_data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-1590-7413-8c82-cc218cff40b4", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "balanced", "densityScore": 27, "componentCount": 4, "textChars": 621, "nDataPoints": 12, "notes": "Contains detailed footnotes referencing former executive interviews and methodology for calculating revenue-sharing obligations.", "elementsJson": [ "paragraph", "footnote" ], "confidence": 0.95, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.727+00", "seconds": 6.214, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/12", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-12", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": { "h": 0.65, "w": 0.7, "x": 0.15, "y": 0.1 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "Textual analysis of retention costs, human-led customer service expenses, and commission obligations for Medicare Advantage members.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.727+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "6c9f1d70-1197-480d-8a25-4bbf75af35b0", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "quote", "text": "“... I'm sure it does add a little bit to it [cost] because if you're talking about retention call, you might be looking at an outbound call, maybe 15 minutes or something like that, 15 to 30 minutes versus an enrollment call is anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour so your cost should be a little bit lower on that front.” — EHTH Former Executive A.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": { "name": "Authority citation", "slug": "authority-citation", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-49ae-7557-89ad-3fca70469b45", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Quoting an authority figure, study, or precedent to lend weight.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-7fb1c3981218", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.1, "w": 0.7, "x": 0.15, "y": 0.8 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "Footnotes 16-19 detailing sources for executive quotes and partnership data.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.727+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "b8404bb3-1517-48d3-8d13-a03871da8a38", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.6, "x": 0.2, "y": 0.755 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Table 7: eHealth Ongoing Costs From Revenue Sharing Partnerships", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:52.727+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "eeed0f2f-5fbc-4bf5-ae6e-23df2a792799", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 12, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 5, "name": "Appendix with Data", "beatId": "5ed51a1a-9643-40ed-92f6-32d4381549ae", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data", "position": 3, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [], "locked": true }, { "page": 13, "type": "analysis", "title": "The slide uses a forensic accounting approach to re-calculate unit economics, contradicting management's growth narrative.", "function": "diagnose_problem", "rawType": "valuation_table", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "valuation_table", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Valuation table", "slug": "valuation_table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-12c3-77cd-8474-6cd39cf844cb", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "diagnose_problem", "functionCanon": { "name": "Diagnose problem", "slug": "diagnose_problem", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-176d-761f-b608-cf52262d2ab2", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "dense", "densityScore": 61, "componentCount": 8, "textChars": 910, "nDataPoints": 40, "notes": "The slide uses a forensic accounting approach to re-calculate unit economics, contradicting management's growth narrative.", "elementsJson": [ "headline_text", "paragraph", "data_table", "valuation_table" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "seconds": 3.05, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/13", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-13", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "When including annual fixed costs in the calculation, we estimate the company will lose -$402 on every MA customer.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-62c0d4ea9e06", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "Contribution Margin: -$402", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-6521effcbf18", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.07, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.24 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "On a unit basis, we conclude the EHTH's MA business is significantly loss-generating. Rather than reflecting 'investment for growth', we believe that EHTH's greatly increasing cash burn shows how value destructive EHTH's pursuit of MA member growth at breakneck speed is.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "3b46aa1e-8c34-4500-ab63-0ca351353c57", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.05, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.85 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "EHTH management has consistently been unable to meet its forecasts of when the company will generate positive operating cash flow. These repeated misses and the resulting cash incineration show the value destruction that is occurring through EHTH's pursuit of growth at all costs.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "a2fa1d0c-429a-40f2-9950-17e430d37a57", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.07, "w": 0.75, "x": 0.13, "y": 0.1 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Impact of Ongoing Partnership Revenue Share on LTV and Costs table", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "68706fe8-f7f1-477d-b7bb-0c39b9b41a2b", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.07, "w": 0.35, "x": 0.32, "y": 0.76 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Table 9: eHealth MA Unit Economics Inclusive of Fixed Costs", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Valuation table", "slug": "valuation", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-034c-74ed-b5c8-22b5e6ac196d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "valuation", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "32599a21-70cf-445e-a458-bc5a03b2edd7", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.12, "w": 0.3, "x": 0.35, "y": 0.51 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Table 8: eHealth MA Unit Economics", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Valuation table", "slug": "valuation", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-034c-74ed-b5c8-22b5e6ac196d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "valuation", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "547a3861-bf83-4c68-bea4-e890a0bc5ce3", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.5, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.21 }, "kind": "title", "text": "EHTH's Medicare Advantage Business is Actually Unprofitable", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "8ed7c5a2-3003-4ccb-87ae-fb8f8b2164cf", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "f05c0b25-08b4-43e6-96e6-9010e580ae54", "evidence": "Calculation of LTV, acquisition costs, and contribution margin per member.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:49.843+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 13, "frameworkName": "unit-economics-analysis" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 13, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 13, "name": "Valuation Table", "beatId": "313b7d4b-d08b-4fcf-881a-6d9569070037", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report presents a valuation table showing EHTH's Medicare Advantage business is significantly loss-generating", "position": 4, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [ { "to": 13, "from": 13, "loop": { "name": "27_cost_of_inaction", "slug": "27-cost-of-inaction", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Urgent budget requests, compliance, risk mitigation", "canonId": "019dd956-70d1-7395-a15b-857ba858b394", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2420-77be-bc41-ded96d08cb21", "structure": "The Status Quo -> The Hidden Costs Accumulating -> The Future State of Inaction -> The Tipping Point", "description": "Quantify what happens if the audience does nothing", "familyLabel": null }, "matchId": "c4f27b16-be6e-4fb3-8ddd-617fe8ec5192", "evidence": "The report presents a valuation table showing the cost of inaction for EHTH's investors", "position": 2, "objective": "What is the cost of inaction for EHTH's investors?", "confidence": 0.6, "extraction": { "at": "2026-07-16 21:58:41.973822+00", "model": "or:meta-llama/llama-4-scout", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": "doc-narrative-v1" } } ], "locked": true }, { "page": 14, "type": "tension", "title": "The slide uses a 'villain_critique' tone, specifically targeting EHTH management's credibility and accounting practices.", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "expose_contradiction", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "expose_contradiction", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-124c-75aa-984a-0a3d0d8fc8df", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "overcrowded", "densityScore": 92, "componentCount": 11, "textChars": 2412, "nDataPoints": 12, "notes": "The slide uses a 'villain_critique' tone, specifically targeting EHTH management's credibility and accounting practices.", "elementsJson": [ "bullet_list", "paragraph", "data_table" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "seconds": 3.894, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/14", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-14", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "EHTH's overstatement of future commissions booked as upfront revenue by approximately $128 million, detailed above, means that sales are exaggerated by 33.8%.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-417ec246aad6", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.18, "w": 0.75, "x": 0.14, "y": 0.14 }, "kind": "list", "text": "In March 2018, Dave Francis said that he expected the Medicare business to become cash flow positive “certainly by 2019”. 2019 company operating cash flow was in fact negative.\nIn February 2019, CFO Derek Yung gave 2019 cash used in operations guidance of -$17 million to -$20 million. The operating cash burn turned out to be -$71.5 million.\nIn February 2019, Mr. Yung also said that management was “targeting” positive OCF for 2020. Only one year later, in February 2020, Mr. Yung said that management expects 2020 cash used in operations to be -$52 million to -$55 million.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "List", "slug": "list", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f94b-779b-a53b-fd4904a5f4d2", "version": 1, "description": "Bullet or numbered list." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Bullet list", "slug": "bullet", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fc98-7169-a083-5cab805076ca", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "bullet", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "f1735eb5-3657-43b5-99d4-73aae669189a", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "Adjusted Operating Profit: -$181.5M", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-4bf38b640795", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.05, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.34 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "Apologists for the company might justify this inability to reach OCF breakeven as a sign of growth. Our response is that the company is prodigiously incinerating cash to grow, and member churn has skyrocketed.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "377917a8-7737-45ac-a763-b8df8a978b46", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.07, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.8 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "EHTH’s overstatement of future commissions booked as upfront revenue by approximately $128 million, detailed above, means that sales are exaggerated by 33.8%. Meanwhile, after stripping out the inflated commissions and adjusting for ongoing costs of approximately $135 million, the company’s operating profit swings to a deep loss, reflecting a lossmaking underlying business", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "93f603a1-3163-4bee-a079-c61ed593a104", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.08, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.46 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "This adjustment assumes that EHTH may apply ASC 606 as it does, which is a proposition with which we wholly disagree. Regardless, we start with a lower LTV for 2019 MA enrollees of $728. Multiplying the LTV difference by 404,694 2019 MA Estimated Members yields a revenue haircut of $115 million from MA alone. Overstated receivables computed similarly across the remainder of the business bring total revenue inflation to $128 million.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "cc7c06a9-eea8-49e1-af45-f9d1bb3f6221", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.03, "w": 0.78, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.09 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "EHTH management has repeatedly had move the goalposts regarding when it expects to generate positive operating cash flow:", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "e2467a10-bf9b-4815-a78c-59e08dc44ded", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "quote", "text": "In March 2018, Dave Francis said that he expected the Medicare business to become cash flow positive “certainly by 2019”. — Dave Francis", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Quote", "slug": "quote", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8fb-751e-8bc6-d58e2d59562a", "version": 1, "description": "Pull quote or testimonial." }, "tool": { "name": "Authority citation", "slug": "authority-citation", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-49ae-7557-89ad-3fca70469b45", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Quoting an authority figure, study, or precedent to lend weight.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-441261a14b2b", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.18, "w": 0.38, "x": 0.31, "y": 0.6 }, "kind": "table", "text": "eHealth Adjusted 2019 Operating Figures ($millions) Stated Revenue 506.2 Remaining Life Overstatement (127.9) Adjusted Revenue 378.3 Stated Operating Profit 81.4 Remaining Life Overstatement (127.9) Retention & Service Cost Impact (135.0) Adjusted Operating Profit (181.5)", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "2bfa00ea-d819-4ecf-bccc-5788d6378e01", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.45, "x": 0.11, "y": 0.42 }, "kind": "title", "text": "We Adjust 2019 Revenue Down by 25%", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "17425f46-c5a1-4b68-a94a-51752e80bc91", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.5, "x": 0.25, "y": 0.56 }, "kind": "title", "text": "Table 10: Revenue and Profit Impact of eHealth Misstatements", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Subtitle", "slug": "subtitle", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb09-739d-900c-815b0d9ac526", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "subtitle", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "5957c9cc-1465-4992-bf8c-94c1a3205178", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "34cbd31a-0ec9-4d4d-9da9-6c33ca3c5e6b", "evidence": "The slide explicitly calculates revenue and profit adjustments to expose accounting misstatements.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.9, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.749+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 14, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 15, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 14, "name": "Final Critique of EHTH", "beatId": "aac76673-f7bf-4429-a612-c39f711d135f", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report concludes with a final critique of EHTH, viewing it as little more than a stock promotion", "position": 5, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [], "locked": true }, { "page": 15, "type": "tension", "title": "The slide uses insider selling data to undermine the credibility of the company's leadership and business model.", "function": "expose_contradiction", "rawType": "villain_critique", "block": null, "metadata": { "slideType": "villain_critique", "slideTypeCanon": { "name": "Villain critique", "slug": "villain_critique", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-10bc-7136-bf20-09de59d17447", "version": 1, "description": null }, "function": "expose_contradiction", "functionCanon": { "name": "Expose contradiction", "slug": "expose_contradiction", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-171f-776f-887c-73edaff4cf9c", "version": 1, "description": null }, "density": "dense", "densityScore": 51, "componentCount": 6, "textChars": 1226, "nDataPoints": 84, "notes": "The slide uses insider selling data to undermine the credibility of the company's leadership and business model.", "elementsJson": [ "headline_text", "paragraph", "data_table", "footnote" ], "confidence": 1, "extraction": { "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.21+00", "seconds": 3.304, "promptVersion": "v2-canon-conditioned" } }, "links": { "slide": "/slides/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e/15", "deck": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e", "deckAnchor": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e#slide-15", "deckJson": "/decks/019dd923-622c-750b-8b97-0bf66d39ad6e.json" }, "components": [ { "bbox": null, "kind": "callout", "text": "We View EHTH as Little More than a Stock Promotion", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Callout", "slug": "callout", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f8d3-761a-8953-7d37080de5e2", "version": 1, "description": "Highlighted callout box." }, "tool": { "name": "Visual emphasis", "slug": "visual-emphasis", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-474b-736b-a8eb-a794dd88241c", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Drawing the eye to one element above the rest of the slide.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-a9399c8ed575", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": null, "kind": "metric", "text": "Net Value Monetized: $34,912,091", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Metric", "slug": "metric", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f923-73bf-8081-d0b1a8c5264d", "version": 1, "description": "Big-number or KPI value." }, "tool": { "name": "Quantification", "slug": "quantification", "status": "active", "bestFor": null, "canonId": "019dd9e1-47ab-72ce-a079-aab1f5299e88", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": null, "description": "Translating a claim into numbers, charts, or tables.", "familyLabel": null }, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": "primary", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-04-22 23:32:46+00", "model": "unknown-legacy", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "019dd953-25b7-709e-b8bd-ad7eaa3ca2f7", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.25, "w": 0.76, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.155 }, "kind": "paragraph", "text": "It is telling that when Mr. Flanders, who had no prior operational experience in healthcare, accepted the CEO job, he brought in an equity analyst as his number two, soon thereafter making him the COO. We found no information to suggest that Dave Francis has an expertise in operating call centers, marketing to consumers, or U.S. government relations. As an equity analyst, however, he presumably knows how to “tell a story”. That story became “We’re the Expedia / Zillow of health insurance”, and when paired with an accounting standard that practically begs for aggressive assumptions and a growth at all costs approach, the stock has ripped on the back of fantasy revenue and earnings. Given that EHTH is already changing its model to ensure 2017 stays relevant, we wonder how long management can keep this charade up – particularly when consistently burning cash. Recent selling by insiders, especially Mr. Flanders (who sold 15% of his stake in January 2020 alone), makes that question all the more pressing.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "5f2affc0-941d-4d07-959d-4bfc1930cea4", "version": 1, "description": "Single prose block in the body of a slide." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Paragraph", "slug": "paragraph", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fb80-75af-aa5c-a7a4bfac2433", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "paragraph", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.21+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "e374d5c5-394c-402a-9480-660c366709ef", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.4, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.89 }, "kind": "source-note", "text": "20 See EHTH 2017 Investor and Analyst Day.", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Source note", "slug": "source-note", "status": "active", "canonId": "23484952-494b-4a5e-b1ad-550d0d70e948", "version": 1, "description": "Attribution / source / caveat placed at the slide footer. Numbered footnotes use attrs.numbered." }, "tool": null, "subkind": null, "framework": null }, "subkind": null, "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.21+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "d05bb024-492b-4075-a250-9ba3b1ceab9d", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.45, "w": 0.48, "x": 0.26, "y": 0.405 }, "kind": "table", "text": "Share Sales at eHealth Since Late 2018", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Table", "slug": "table", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f9c8-7148-8119-eaac9594cd28", "version": 1, "description": "Tabular data layout." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Data table", "slug": "data", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52d-02d5-75b8-8abf-88e92bf63569", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "data", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.21+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "ddd2de88-90cd-4230-a8aa-3574c57333d3", "parentComponentId": null }, { "bbox": { "h": 0.02, "w": 0.58, "x": 0.118, "y": 0.118 }, "kind": "title", "text": "We View EHTH as Little More than a Stock Promotion", "attrs": null, "canon": { "kind": { "name": "Title", "slug": "title", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-f7dd-76d9-b848-b1f12bd85cf4", "version": 1, "description": "Slide title or headline." }, "tool": null, "subkind": { "name": "Headline", "slug": "headline", "status": "active", "canonId": "019de52c-fae1-7463-9a7c-d60668eced0d", "version": 1, "description": null }, "framework": null }, "subkind": "headline", "groupRole": null, "confidence": null, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.21+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "componentId": "8c0d335a-b19c-4ed2-9803-c6f882d320cf", "parentComponentId": null } ], "metrics": [], "tools": [], "frameworks": [ { "matchId": "eb77aec3-b48a-42f4-9c01-2effba981489", "evidence": "The slide explicitly frames the company as a 'stock promotion' and 'charade' based on insider selling and lack of operational expertise.", "framework": null, "confidence": 0.95, "extraction": { "at": "2026-05-02 20:48:50.21+00", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview-20260303", "runId": null, "seconds": null, "promptVersion": null }, "pageNumber": 15, "frameworkName": "fraud-exposure" } ], "arcBeats": [ { "to": 15, "arc": { "name": "Overcoming the Monster", "slug": "overcoming-monster", "status": "active", "bestFor": "Competitive positioning, rallying teams", "canonId": "019dd956-6339-76ac-9cbf-4b377c3aa89e", "version": 1, "bodyDocId": "019df22a-2356-73eb-8061-d8c81dc0aa49", "structure": "The Monster -> The Call -> The Struggle -> The Victory -> The New Order", "description": null, "familyLabel": null }, "from": 14, "name": "Final Critique of EHTH", "beatId": "aac76673-f7bf-4429-a612-c39f711d135f", "matchId": "a4b3f769-2b87-44f3-a336-f52bfc7620b0", "beatType": null, "evidence": "The report concludes with a final critique of EHTH, viewing it as little more than a stock promotion", "position": 5, "isPrimaryArc": true, "parentBeatType": null, "alignedBlockIds": null, "matchConfidence": 0.8 } ], "loops": [], "locked": true } ], "arcBeats": [ { "from": 1, "to": 3, "label": "Disclaimer and Executive Summary", "description": "The report begins with a disclaimer and executive summary, setting the tone for the rest of the report" }, { "from": 4, "to": 7, "label": "Critique of EHTH's Business Practices", "description": "The report critiques EHTH's business practices, including its overly optimistic member persistence assumptions" }, { "from": 8, "to": 11, "label": "Exposure of EHTH's Contradictions", "description": "The report exposes contradictions in EHTH's business practices, including its deliberate obscuring of increasing churn rates" }, { "from": 5, "to": 12, "label": "Appendix with Data", "description": "The report includes tables and data to support its claims, including churn rates and financial data" }, { "from": 13, "to": 13, "label": "Valuation Table", "description": "The report presents a valuation table showing EHTH's Medicare Advantage business is significantly loss-generating" }, { "from": 14, "to": 15, "label": "Final Critique of EHTH", "description": "The report concludes with a final critique of EHTH, viewing it as little more than a stock promotion" } ], "loops": [ { "from": 4, "to": 7, "label": "Zoom In", "description": "What are EHTH's business practices and financials?" }, { "from": 8, "to": 11, "label": "Iceberg", "description": "What are the implications of EHTH's contradictions?" }, { "from": 13, "to": 13, "label": "Cost Of Inaction", "description": "What is the cost of inaction for EHTH's investors?" } ] }